Comments on: Snape: “Harry, I am your father.” http://www.bonniewren.com/2005/snape-harry-i-am-your-father.htm I fought the lawn... and the lawn won Sun, 20 Jul 2008 21:07:09 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5.1 By: Richard R http://www.bonniewren.com/2005/snape-harry-i-am-your-father.htm#comment-269 Richard R Sun, 27 Nov 2005 17:49:17 +0000 http://www.bonniewren.com/more/?p=128#comment-269 Why would you think it's a joke? It seems likely to me. Snape has never done anything to hurt Harry, other than sneer. He kept Voldamort from killing him in the first book. It's obvious that Snape and Dumbledore had HBP's events planned. And Dumbledore has said he had an iron clad guarentee of Snape's good behavior. What could be more iron clad? There's an old JKR interview where she was asked "Isn't it all about Snape's redemption" and she changed the subject. Why would you think it’s a joke? It seems likely to me.

Snape has never done anything to hurt Harry, other than sneer. He kept Voldamort from killing him in the first book. It’s obvious that Snape and Dumbledore had HBP’s events planned. And Dumbledore has said he had an iron clad guarentee of Snape’s good behavior. What could be more iron clad?

There’s an old JKR interview where she was asked “Isn’t it all about Snape’s redemption” and she changed the subject.

]]> By: Bonnie Wren http://www.bonniewren.com/2005/snape-harry-i-am-your-father.htm#comment-151 Bonnie Wren Fri, 28 Oct 2005 16:52:30 +0000 http://www.bonniewren.com/more/?p=128#comment-151 My thoughts exactly. I think Snape's going to turn out to be a good guy. An unlikable, greasy-haired good guy, but a good guy all the same. My thoughts exactly. I think Snape’s going to turn out to be a good guy.

An unlikable, greasy-haired good guy, but a good guy all the same.

]]> By: Sammy http://www.bonniewren.com/2005/snape-harry-i-am-your-father.htm#comment-148 Sammy Thu, 27 Oct 2005 08:00:43 +0000 http://www.bonniewren.com/more/?p=128#comment-148 Also that argument they had near hagrids hut, what if Snape didn`t want to be a death eater anymore and wanted to die rather that do what he had promised narcissa to do... and when Dumbledore pleaded, maybe he was pleading for Snape to kill him, and thats why he looked like he hated dumbledore, for him making him to kill him... plus he went schitzo when called a coward for killing dumbledore... maybe it took more courage than we all realised... ? Also that argument they had near hagrids hut, what if Snape didn`t want to be a death eater anymore and wanted to die rather that do what he had promised narcissa to do… and when Dumbledore pleaded, maybe he was pleading for Snape to kill him, and thats why he looked like he hated dumbledore, for him making him to kill him… plus he went schitzo when called a coward for killing dumbledore… maybe it took more courage than we all realised… ?

]]>